Construction’s slipper still doesn’t fit
Posted: 19th February 2015
Graham Watts OBE
A 36-year perspective on construction has been one series of very long loops. On the one hand, there has been the continual drive – from the top – to improve the industry’s efficiency with strategic reports coming along at an ever-increasing frequency. Introducing ‘Constructing The Team’ - in 1994 - the author, Sir Michael Latham, remarked that it had been 15 years since the Banwell Report and he hoped that there would not need to be another seminal report about construction in the next 15 years.
"The “Cinderella” industry has at long last found a Prince Charming in Government (and he can dance, too) now that we have a Secretary of State for Business (Vince Cable) who recognises that no other sector can function without an effective construction industry."
But by 2010, there had been four more major overhaul reviews (2 x Egan, Wolstenholme and Morrell)!
The current iteration of all this motherhood and apple pie (for every report has articulated the blindingly obvious about how to make a better industry) is the Industrial Strategy, which merits some higher level of consideration since it, at least, places construction amongst and alongside the other major industrial sectors of the UK economy.
The “Cinderella” industry has at long last found a Prince Charming in Government (and he can dance, too) now that we have a Secretary of State for Business ( Vince Cable) who recognises that no other sector of the British economy can function without an effective construction industry.
But, to carry this “Into the Woods” analogy one step further, the slipper still doesn’t fit. Despite all the reports, we remain an industry that doesn’t train its own people in sufficient numbers, has an appalling record on diversity, requires a convoluted supply chain to construct a large shed and doesn’t pass on the payments fairly down to the people who actually turn up to do the work.
The other series of loops I’ve witnessed over the past 36 years has been the eternal cycle of boom and bust. We go from throwing good people onto the scrapheap to bemoaning skills shortages, sometimes seemingly without pausing for breath. The short-termism of the industry never ceases to amaze me. Companies’ breeze through the good times without – it appears – bothering much to prepare for the fact that they will not last forever. When the recession comes, we mostly seem to be ill-prepared.
"Frankly, it’s a cop-out. No other economic sector has certainty of demand."
Now, we are obsessed with creating pipelines of work. It seems like a great idea. Spreading the workload evenly - like marmite on a piece of toast - will ensure a regularity of provision and guard against the inevitable inflationary pressure of too much, too soon. A National Infrastructure Pipeline is a good thing but as a necessity for the client – and here the collective client is the UK taxpayer – rather than industry.
The problem now comes with the industry believing that the pipeline is there for its own sake to provide a steady and unencumbered forward flow of work. I hear this refrain frequently from industry trade associations who would like to see the “pipeline” concept extended to every area of demand, even into the private sector. “Give us certainty of work, going forward, and we can invest in the people we need”, is the sort of plea I hear.
Frankly, it’s a cop-out. No other economic sector has certainty of demand. The biggest single thought, garnered from these 36 years’ experience, is the certainty that this industry needs an entirely new business model. And time is running out.
Graham Watts OBE
Graham has been involved with CIC since 1989. Initially, as a member of the Council, it’s Executive Board and then as a Director. He was appointed Chief Executive and Secretary in October 1991. Prior to joining CIC, Graham was Chief Executive of the British Institute of Architectural Technologists (a member of CIC) from 1983.
Graham is responsible for the general policy and direction of the Council, for maintaining effective communication with Government, other external agencies and with members and for establishing and maintaining the CIC Secretariat and office.
Graham is an Honorary Fellow of RIBA, CIBSE, CABE, ICWCI, BIID, CICES and the Faculty of Building and an Honorary Member of the RICS and CIAT. He was awarded the President’s Medal of the CIOB in 2000 and the Peter Stone Award of the Association of Building Engineers in 1996.
Graham is currently a director of CIC Approved Inspectors Register (CICAIR Ltd); Construction Umbrella Bodies (Holdings) Ltd; the Considerate Constructors’ Scheme; and Constructionarium Ltd. He was a Visiting Professor at the University of Northumbria for twelve years from 2000. He has been Secretary of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Excellence in the Built Environment since 2010.
Graham is a member of the Industry Response Group, set up by the MHCLG in the immediate aftermath of the Grenfell Tower tragedy and Chaired the Competence Working Group set up to assist Dame Judith Hackitt’s Review of Building Regulations and Fire Safety. Following the report publication he is now Chair of the Steering Group charged with implementing the recommendations on improving competence for all those engaged in designing, construction, managing and maintaining higher-risk residential buildings, this includes oversight of the competence work being carried out in the Fire and Rescue Services.
Graham had a long involvement in the sport of fencing and his competitive career culminated with a Commonwealth Medal in 1990. In 1992, he captained the British Sabre team at the Barcelona Olympic Games. He was the Manager of the British Fencing Team from 1996 and the Performance Director of the British Olympic Fencing Team for 10 years from 2000 to 2010, and Team Leader at the 2004 and 2008 Olympics Games.
Outside of CIC, he is an established international dance writer and critic. He is a member of The Critics’ Circle, the UNESCO Dance Council, Dance UK and the Society of Dance Research. He has been Chairman of the Dance Section of the Critics’ Circle since 2009 and of the National Dance Awards since 2010. In 2012, he was author of Daria Klimentová’s Autobiography “Agony and Ecstasy: My Life in Dance”.
Graham received an OBE in the New Years Honours in 2008 for his services to the construction industry.
Share this story:
Telephone: 020 7399 7400